The Future of Council Tax: Evolution or Revolution

Evolution or Revolution

Council Tax has been a fixture since its introduction in the early 1990s. Often described as a property tax, it is more accurately considered a property and household tax. As the socio-economic landscape evolves and public dissatisfaction with the current system grows, the question arises: should the future of Council Tax be shaped by gradual evolution or radical revolution? This was a hot topic at the IRRV Spring Conference. Here is my take on it.

Context and Current Structure

Council Tax replaced the unpopular Community Charge (or “Poll Tax”), aiming to create a fairer system based on property values rather than a flat rate per person. With properties set into bands authorities set their own rates within a framework determined by central government, allowing for some regional variability. Despite its intent, Council Tax has faced criticism over issues of fairness and adequacy. The valuation bands, based on 1991 property prices, are outdated, leading to disparities as property values have shifted significantly over the past three decades. Additionally, the system’s regressive nature can lead to lower-income households often paying a higher proportion of their income compared to wealthier households.

The Case for Evolution

Evolutionary changes to Council Tax could address many of its current shortcomings without the disruption of a complete overhaul. Possible reforms voiced include:

  • Revaluation of Properties – Regular updates to property valuations which could ensure that tax bands reflect current market values, addressing disparities and ensuring a fairer distribution of tax burdens
  • Band Expansion and Redistribution – Introducing more bands, especially at the higher end, could create a more progressive system. This would ensure that those with the most expensive properties contribute a fairer share relative to their property wealth
  • Enhanced Local Autonomy – Allowing local authorities greater flexibility in setting rates and introducing local supplements for specific projects could enhance the responsiveness of Council Tax to local needs
  • Targeted Reliefs and Rebates – Expanding means-tested rebates and introducing reliefs for low-income households can mitigate the regressive impacts of Council Tax. If not funded effectively though this will place additional strain on already stretched local budgets 
  • Integration with Other Local Taxes – Streamlining Council Tax with business rates and other local levies could improve efficiency and reduce administrative costs

Evolutionary changes to Council Tax could address many of its current shortcomings without the disruption of a complete overhaul with the changes offering the benefit of incremental improvement, ensuring stability while addressing disparities and promoting fairness in tax distribution.

The Case for Revolution

While evolutionary changes offer incremental improvements, some continue to argue that only a revolutionary approach can address the fundamental flaws that exist with the current Council Tax scheme. Proposals for a revolutionary transformation include:

  • A Land Value Tax (LVT) – Replacing Council Tax with a tax based on land value rather than property value could promote fairness and efficiency. A LVT taxes the unimproved value of land, encouraging better land use and reducing speculative holding
  • Local Income Tax – Shifting to a local income tax could align tax burdens more closely with the taxpayer’s ability to pay. This approach would be more progressive, ensuring that higher earners contribute proportionately more
  • A Combined Property and Income Tax – A hybrid system could balance the benefits of property taxation with the fairness of income taxation, ensuring that both wealth and ability to pay are considered
  • Reform of Funding Mechanisms – Beyond changing the tax itself, revolution could involve restructuring how local services are funded. This might include greater central government funding or new models of municipal finance such as local bonds or participatory budgeting. For instance, many advocate that social care should be funded from a central pool

While evolutionary changes offer gradual progress, some argue that only revolutionary reforms can effectively address the fundamental flaws of Council Tax. Proposals such as implementing a LVT, shifting to a local income tax, or combining property and income taxes offer clear benefits, promoting fairness and alignment with taxpayers’ ability to pay. Ultimately, these radical reforms aim to create a more equitable and sustainable taxation system.

Political and Social Considerations

The choice between evolution and revolution involves not only technical and economic considerations but also political and social ones. 

Evolutionary changes are often more politically palatable, as they promise improvements without the uncertainty and resistance associated with sweeping reforms. However, revolutionary changes, though riskier, offer the potential for a more equitable and sustainable system in the long run. 

In my opinion the public doesn’t necessarily care about the taxation mechanisms as long as they can understand it and ultimately pay less in the long run, preferably with fewer significant increases. There is a growing consensus, especially amongst practitioners, that something needs to be done about extreme wealth and its impact on the fairness of taxation systems.

With a General Election now scheduled for July and a possible change in power, a revolutionary approach is unlikely to occur in the first term of a new government. Such significant changes might be reserved for the start of a change in government’s second term.


The future of Council Tax is at a crossroads, with both evolutionary and revolutionary paths offering distinct advantages. While evolutionary reforms promise incremental improvements and stability, a revolutionary approach could address deeper structural issues and create a fairer, more efficient system. Any change that has a significant impact, however, will need to be phased in to ensure taxpayers have the consistency required to manage their personal finances effectively.

Ultimately, the choice will depend on balancing the desire for equity and efficiency with political feasibility and public acceptance. As we move forward, the debate between evolution and revolution will continue to shape the landscape of local taxation and public finance.

About Steven Rybaruk

Steve joined Liberata in 2003 and has over 25 years of experience in the Revenues & Assessment field in both the public and private sectors. He is a key member of the Senior Management Team, leading the Revenues & Assessments Solutions & Innovation functions. Steve is responsible for the Future Operating Model, service strategy, and benchmarking program, ensuring cost-effective and high-value solutions for local government clients.

See how Liberata can help your organisation.

Book A Demo
As a Council we are focused on ensuring that the services delivered are both sustainable and of the highest quality. We are delighted to be working with Liberata to help deliver these services on behalf of our residents and businesses. Liberata stood out with its ability to drive transformational change and improve customer access and digital services.
Richard Baker
Welwyn Hatfield Borough Council
Liberata is the ideal delivery partner to help us achieve our aims, whilst ensuring we can drive down processing times and improve the service for our customers. Council tax and business rates collection will improve, ensuring that we have the funds to deliver the vital services that have a positive impact on residents’ lives. We look forward to working closely in partnership with Liberata to help achieve our aims
Rebecca Keene
Broxbourne Borough Council
Eastleigh Borough Council has worked with Liberata for a number of years who undertake the council's empty home reviews, and I must say, their service exceeded all expectations. From start to finish, they demonstrated professionalism, efficiency, and a genuine commitment to addressing this critical issue in our community. Thanks to Liberata, the council has been able to maximise our empty home bonus year on year. This positive impact on our community cannot be overstated.
Kerrie Thomas
Eastleigh Borough Council
The RV Finder service from Liberata has really helped us ensure that our data is as accurate as possible and, when the VOA has processed the outstanding cases, I fully expect to see more than £1,000,000 of additional RV. The “risk and reward” model works well and the Council only has to pay for their success and the service is something that we will use on a regular basis.
Steve King
Leicester City Council
Liberata has been empowered to create a seamless integration with technology to digitally transform the Revenues and Benefits service whilst trying to protect local jobs. The joint strategy has helped to deliver innovative solutions that have exceeded expectations, whilst providing savings to the authority. This surge in digital engagement has helped deliver strong year one outturn with electronic billing and the technology will enable us to show improvements in the benefits speed of processing and in Council Tax processing of moves, discounts and exemptions.
Andy Stevens
Swindon Borough Council